In the Idea Hive class we read the book Half Brother by Kenneth Oppel over Skype. The book is about a chimpanzee that learns to speak sign language. Then we watched the documentary on the true story, Project Nim. After that we were asked what similarities and differences did you notice between Half Brother and Project Nim? What surprised you most in the documentary? What were you most disturbed about? What were you happiest about? What did you learn from the documentary that you hadn’t thought of before?
The first similarity I noticed was in both stories the chimp started its life in a human household. Also both chimps were taken from their mother at birth. Both the chimps had similar first signs that they used frequently, for example hug and play. Next I saw that the chimps moved around a lot from home to laboratory to ranch. Right when they started to settle in their new home, they were moved again. The last similarity I noticed was how each chimp was saved from being at a lab with help from the media.
The first difference I noticed was that in Project Nim there was no logbooks and very little to no structure. In Half Brother every part of Zan’s life was recorded. The next difference I noticed was in the documentary the chimp, Nim, was allowed to smoke and do drugs which did not happen in the book Half Brother. In the story Nim was sold to a bio lab and in Half Brother Zan was saved before being taken to the lab. The last difference I noticed was that Nim seemed to need a lot more attention than Zan. Nim would get angry and break things if he did not have company.
I learned from the documentary chimps bite a lot. Next I learned that chimps are very forgiving animals. Nim was not mad when his previous owner Herb came to visit after leaving him at a “chimp prison”. Also I learned that chimps are very social animals and need attention. When Nim was left in a cage by himself he was very angry and smashed anything he could. Chimps are born to challenge other males. Nim was always trying to make any male figures in his life angry by knocking books off the shelf or biting. Finally I learned in the documentary no matter what you do if you’re testing medication on animals it will never be humain.
I found it disturbing that they allowed Nim to smoke and do drugs. Also I thought it was wrong to electrocute the chimps with a prod. If the chimps were misbehaving they would get a shock. Next I didn’t like it when Nim was taken to the Bio lab. He and other chimps were kept in tiny cages and had various things tested on them. Another thing I found disturbing was how after he was taken to the Bio lab, they just left Nim in a cage alone and angry. He needed contact with people or other chimps, but was just left by himself.
I found it happy how much Nim loved to stay at the University estate with Laura. Nim got to play and enjoyed the company of people. Also I was happy for Nim when even after all the time had past Bob came back and was Nim’s friend. I was happy when Nim was taken out of the Bio lab to the ranch but not after I realized he was going to be there all alone. It was really nice when Chris took over the ranch and got friends for Nim.

cc licensed ( BY ) flickr photo shared by timparkinson
Do you think it was right to move an animal around so much soon as it became accustomed to it?





